Nice work. This is a very good way of presenting information. Painful to look at, but inspiring too, and it makes points that are hard to make without folks tuning out. This is a lot more than a list of names, and some numbers. Such good work.
Thanks again. What is spectacularly gruesome about this situation is that this is all occurring under the legal permitting process. There are no accidents associated with these quickly deteriorating and unsustainable conditions. All are occurring quite legally. In fact the 18.4 million pounds of toxic releases into our air-shed are self reported. These industries are quite capable of navigating the permitting and legal systems. They pose no risk to them, for the economies of scale work in their favor. There are consequences, however, other than financial, to the notion “Too Big to fail.” It is often thought that only astronomers work with big numbers, well, I’m here to say - so do our great polluters.
No one has the time, money or inclination to review these numbers. A good example of the lack of oversight is how BP was able to evade detection of their illegal benzene releases for more than 6 years (the span of my daughter’s entire life), which are not part of the TRI (95 tons of benzene waste in 2008 — nearly 16 times the 6 tons allowed under permitting)
Let’s remember that it only takes one-part-per-million of benzene to cause cancer. I suppose this is a risk American’s are willing to force the people of East Chicago to take - Ain’t democracy swell? Well, it ain’t working for me. Do you suppose it is possible to conclusively attribute any future cancers in my community or family to this exposure? And differentiate it from all other known risk factors in this community. No, probably not - And that is how BP gains an awesome financial benefit (somewhere in the range of $10 billion in profits quarterly) by shifting the risks to the tissues and life sustaining systems of the people in my fence-line industrial community.
Perhaps someday we will decode the signatures associated with accumulated factors for illness in each individual.
Let me draw a comparison about the oil plumb that sits under my house. As America grows more concerned about the 200,000 gallons per day of oil released into the Gulf by BP, we have ~16.8 million gallons of oil contaminating our groundwater here on the Southern Shores of Lake Michigan - the worlds greatest fresh water resource (or is it any longer?). At 200,000 gallons/day, it would take more than 84 day of continued releases to measure up to what has been allowed to occur here.
Thomas, I don’t think democracy has much to do with it. I don’t think we have anything like democracy. I think we have oligarchic rule. And part of that is the choking media presence in folks lives, media that relentlessly project ideas into people’s heads that they can’t really keep out if they wanted too. One of those ideas is the twisted notion of self-reliance that makes the individual person or community at fault for whatever happens to them. I think that people are naturally very empathetic, and that without such messaging, and with a true democracy, such burdens as you mention would NOT be inflicted on communities, or not nearly as much and not with such impunity.
But how to deconstruct all that manipulation and control, the pyramidal structuring of society? That’s where artists come in, because it takes ideas to counter ideas…
You end with the “Artist” as a counter to the ills of our political/economy. Knowing a little of your understanding of the artist I fully agree with you.
A problem we face is that there are an enormous number of very able and competent people working in our popular visual culture who contract with and are employed by these agents. To be nice - despite their visual achievements, their work simply lacks any critical or complex acuity/thinking. They are just producing for a fee. You see this in every corporate presentation, from the oil industry to technology to the financial industry. What gets me is that these same “visual artist” will then volunteer or offer up their skills for other “good causes” WTF! All they are producing are lifestyle choices in a mass-customized, green branded cluster-fuck. They are simply continuing the prevailing political/economy in a mass-customized FASHION.
Too often it is a fight between visual artists to control the message. On the one side you have the highly capitalized visual artist employed by industry and on the other you may have the same visual artists working to counter the industry message or some under capitalized visual artists with critical acuity.
Yes, yes, yes. You are so right. I was just trying to end on an up note, but yes, it was a sort of silly thing to say. Art is just one more battleground, in a sense, and as always, money seems to talk louder, much louder than anything else. Money can recruit more artists, provide them more resources, and project their ‘work’ much more powerfully…
I’ve been looking for these kinds of numbers for weeks on the web via the NW Indiana media and other websites, knowing that collectively the amount of toxic dumping (and all legal) is staggering. This graphic display dramatically makes the point. I’d like to know where you got some of these figures. I’ve been reading your site and blog for the past two days and can’t get enough. I’m most impressed, too, because you speak from living in the shadows of this plume as do you children. The statistic that hit home to me the other day doing research for an essay that I’m writing (more on that in a separate email) was that children in the East Chicago Schools most play in the worst and most toxic environment in the USA. Thanks for putting it all together. I’m passing on your site to friends, writers and activists I know. By the way, my essay describes my walk from Rogers Park in Chicago through Calumet’s Industrial region to the Indiana Dunes Natl. Lake shore. 55 miles in two days. The point was to bring light to disparities in lake access across the region and to push for a green way for not just biking but for WALKING. I’m writing a book about walking and it’s multiple benefits for human, social and environmental health.
Thanks, please pass this on far and wide. The data is drawn from the EPA’s environ map data sets, the Toxic Release inventories (TRI), Area of Concern (AOC) data on the Grand Calumet and Indiana Harbor Shipping Canal, and East Chicago’s Comprehensive Plan.
I’ve spoken several times about the “Black Hole” of identity and information that exists around this region. This process of selective inattention benefits and protects the image of our nations most corrupt industrial polluters.
Political corruption in the region is driven and financed by these same industrial interests. How else can you explain the millions-of-dollars for local political campaigns in this very poor community with few local businesses. These campaigns are financed by those interests with the most to benefit (Billions-of-dollars annually) - BP, ArcelorMittal, and US Steel. You ought to come down a witness the next Mayoral race which is heating up right now - It will blow your mind the amount of money that is thrown around this community. In the region their are plenty of political operatives to broker these exchanges. The most influential broker is Mitch Daniels himself. From Mitch you can draw a line to many of our political street dealers such as Bobby Cantrel, Cappas, Mark Lopez, etc.
Hey, I’m impressed with your website management and writing skills, makes me wish I had started younger. I was wondering if you could please help me with my blog, it’s in a similar niche. I’ll be willing to pay you of course, how about $300 for 10 articles that are as good as the ones here, does that sound fair? I really need them today or as soon as you get this. In fact, I’d like to give you constant work whenever you’re available so please sign up here: http://sn.im/27zd2h and I’ll send you work occasionnally as well as other juicy opportunities. I’ll hook you up. Thanks! (And yes, this is a real person and I really do need your help)
Nice work. This is a very good way of presenting information. Painful to look at, but inspiring too, and it makes points that are hard to make without folks tuning out. This is a lot more than a list of names, and some numbers. Such good work.
Thanks again. What is spectacularly gruesome about this situation is that this is all occurring under the legal permitting process. There are no accidents associated with these quickly deteriorating and unsustainable conditions. All are occurring quite legally. In fact the 18.4 million pounds of toxic releases into our air-shed are self reported. These industries are quite capable of navigating the permitting and legal systems. They pose no risk to them, for the economies of scale work in their favor. There are consequences, however, other than financial, to the notion “Too Big to fail.” It is often thought that only astronomers work with big numbers, well, I’m here to say - so do our great polluters.
No one has the time, money or inclination to review these numbers. A good example of the lack of oversight is how BP was able to evade detection of their illegal benzene releases for more than 6 years (the span of my daughter’s entire life), which are not part of the TRI (95 tons of benzene waste in 2008 — nearly 16 times the 6 tons allowed under permitting)
“Oil refinery draws fire after EPA cites release of benzene in Whiting” By Gitte Laasby
Let’s remember that it only takes one-part-per-million of benzene to cause cancer. I suppose this is a risk American’s are willing to force the people of East Chicago to take - Ain’t democracy swell? Well, it ain’t working for me. Do you suppose it is possible to conclusively attribute any future cancers in my community or family to this exposure? And differentiate it from all other known risk factors in this community. No, probably not - And that is how BP gains an awesome financial benefit (somewhere in the range of $10 billion in profits quarterly) by shifting the risks to the tissues and life sustaining systems of the people in my fence-line industrial community.
Perhaps someday we will decode the signatures associated with accumulated factors for illness in each individual.
Let me draw a comparison about the oil plumb that sits under my house. As America grows more concerned about the 200,000 gallons per day of oil released into the Gulf by BP, we have ~16.8 million gallons of oil contaminating our groundwater here on the Southern Shores of Lake Michigan - the worlds greatest fresh water resource (or is it any longer?). At 200,000 gallons/day, it would take more than 84 day of continued releases to measure up to what has been allowed to occur here.
Thomas,
Is it possible to explain exactly what all the categories are?
EPA Superfund Site, Underground Storage Tanks, CDF/CAMU, Waste Transfer Station, etc …
Thanks Mike. I am going to update the post with these classifications.
Thomas, I don’t think democracy has much to do with it. I don’t think we have anything like democracy. I think we have oligarchic rule. And part of that is the choking media presence in folks lives, media that relentlessly project ideas into people’s heads that they can’t really keep out if they wanted too. One of those ideas is the twisted notion of self-reliance that makes the individual person or community at fault for whatever happens to them. I think that people are naturally very empathetic, and that without such messaging, and with a true democracy, such burdens as you mention would NOT be inflicted on communities, or not nearly as much and not with such impunity.
But how to deconstruct all that manipulation and control, the pyramidal structuring of society? That’s where artists come in, because it takes ideas to counter ideas…
Paul, I agree.
You end with the “Artist” as a counter to the ills of our political/economy. Knowing a little of your understanding of the artist I fully agree with you.
A problem we face is that there are an enormous number of very able and competent people working in our popular visual culture who contract with and are employed by these agents. To be nice - despite their visual achievements, their work simply lacks any critical or complex acuity/thinking. They are just producing for a fee. You see this in every corporate presentation, from the oil industry to technology to the financial industry. What gets me is that these same “visual artist” will then volunteer or offer up their skills for other “good causes” WTF! All they are producing are lifestyle choices in a mass-customized, green branded cluster-fuck. They are simply continuing the prevailing political/economy in a mass-customized FASHION.
Too often it is a fight between visual artists to control the message. On the one side you have the highly capitalized visual artist employed by industry and on the other you may have the same visual artists working to counter the industry message or some under capitalized visual artists with critical acuity.
Yes, yes, yes. You are so right. I was just trying to end on an up note, but yes, it was a sort of silly thing to say. Art is just one more battleground, in a sense, and as always, money seems to talk louder, much louder than anything else. Money can recruit more artists, provide them more resources, and project their ‘work’ much more powerfully…
Thomas,
I’ve been looking for these kinds of numbers for weeks on the web via the NW Indiana media and other websites, knowing that collectively the amount of toxic dumping (and all legal) is staggering. This graphic display dramatically makes the point. I’d like to know where you got some of these figures. I’ve been reading your site and blog for the past two days and can’t get enough. I’m most impressed, too, because you speak from living in the shadows of this plume as do you children. The statistic that hit home to me the other day doing research for an essay that I’m writing (more on that in a separate email) was that children in the East Chicago Schools most play in the worst and most toxic environment in the USA. Thanks for putting it all together. I’m passing on your site to friends, writers and activists I know. By the way, my essay describes my walk from Rogers Park in Chicago through Calumet’s Industrial region to the Indiana Dunes Natl. Lake shore. 55 miles in two days. The point was to bring light to disparities in lake access across the region and to push for a green way for not just biking but for WALKING. I’m writing a book about walking and it’s multiple benefits for human, social and environmental health.
Michael,
Thanks, please pass this on far and wide. The data is drawn from the EPA’s environ map data sets, the Toxic Release inventories (TRI), Area of Concern (AOC) data on the Grand Calumet and Indiana Harbor Shipping Canal, and East Chicago’s Comprehensive Plan.
I’ve spoken several times about the “Black Hole” of identity and information that exists around this region. This process of selective inattention benefits and protects the image of our nations most corrupt industrial polluters.
Political corruption in the region is driven and financed by these same industrial interests. How else can you explain the millions-of-dollars for local political campaigns in this very poor community with few local businesses. These campaigns are financed by those interests with the most to benefit (Billions-of-dollars annually) - BP, ArcelorMittal, and US Steel. You ought to come down a witness the next Mayoral race which is heating up right now - It will blow your mind the amount of money that is thrown around this community. In the region their are plenty of political operatives to broker these exchanges. The most influential broker is Mitch Daniels himself. From Mitch you can draw a line to many of our political street dealers such as Bobby Cantrel, Cappas, Mark Lopez, etc.
Hey, I’m impressed with your website management and writing skills, makes me wish I had started younger. I was wondering if you could please help me with my blog, it’s in a similar niche. I’ll be willing to pay you of course, how about $300 for 10 articles that are as good as the ones here, does that sound fair? I really need them today or as soon as you get this. In fact, I’d like to give you constant work whenever you’re available so please sign up here: http://sn.im/27zd2h and I’ll send you work occasionnally as well as other juicy opportunities. I’ll hook you up. Thanks! (And yes, this is a real person and I really do need your help)